Spicy Orange Muddled Margarita Recipe

I love margaritas and I especially love muddled margaritas.  Muddling the fruit all the flavor of both the juice and the zest. 

Just make sure you thoroughly clean your citrus and other fruit you plan to muddle.  


The best Margaritas use fresh everything – fruit, lime + quality tequila, and good orange liqueur, like Cointreau or Grand Marnier.

This recipe adds a little muddled orange and jalapeno. 

Simple, easy, stress-free.

Tips to Make Perfect Muddled Margaritas

#1 Use Good Tequila

For the best results use a high-quality tequila, made with 100 percent agave.  High quality doesn’t need to be expensive.  There are a lot of tequilas on the market today, check reviews, and ask for recommendations from the liquor store staff.

#2 Use Fresh Lime Juice

For me, there’s nothing better than a perfectly mixed margarita.  And fresh lime juice is part of my must-have ingredients.  Grab a bag of lime and a low priced juicer – I bought one on Amazon for under $20.

I save single-serve glass juice bottles and use those to store my fresh squeezed lime juice.  It will keep for at least a week in the refrigerator.  If I don’t use it all during the week, I’ll stick it in the freezer and freeze until I need it again.

#3 Make Sure You Wash the Fruit

You’ll want to make sure you’ve thoroughly washed and dried the fruit before using it in your cocktail.

#4 Use High-Quality Triple Sec

Triple Sec is an orange liqueur.  And as the popularity of drinks that use Triple Sec grew, so did the number of cheap, way too sweet options.  My bar is stocked with Grand Marnier, Cointreau, and something blue to make my signature mermaid + tiki drinks!  In the blue department, I like Drillaud Blue Curacao (inexpensive), Giffard Blue Curacao, or Senior “The Genuine” Blue Curacao. I can work with Bols Blue Curacao if it’s all I can find. Skip the really inexpensive like Dekuyper, unless you really want sweet.

You want to look for a Triple Sec that is 78 – 80 poof.  Lower alcohol usually means sweeter and lower quality.

Serious Eats has a really great article to learn more about orange liqueurs.  Click to read.

# 5 Use a Wood Muddler


#6 Don’t over Muddle

Over muddling your fruits and herbs can release bitter chemicals, so muddle just enough to release the juices and oils.  A couple of turns should be enough.


Let’s make a Spicy Orange Muddled Margaritas!

This will make two cocktails, to make a pitcher just change the number of servings and the recipe will recalculate.  Simple, right?



🧜‍♀️ ❤️


Spicy Orange Muddled Margarita Recipe

Prep Time: 10 minutes
Total Time: 10 minutes
Servings: 2
Calories: 340kcal
The best Margaritas use fresh lime + quality tequila and good orange liqueur, like Cointreau or Grand Marnier. Simple, easy, stress-free. For the best results use a high-quality tequila, made with 100 percent agave. For this margarita, I like to use an oaky reposado or  Anejo
For me, there's nothing better than a perfectly mixed margarita. + I love a little bit of heat. So this is one of my favorite versions of the margarita.
This will make two cocktails, to make a pitcher just change the number of servings and the recipe will recalculate.  Simple, right.
Print Recipe


  • 4 oz Reposado or  Anejo tequila
  • 2 oz fresh lime juice
  • 2 oz orange juice
  • 1/2 lime - cut into 4 wedges
  • 1/2 orange - cut into 8 wedges
  • 1 oz simple syrup
  • 1 oz Cointreau or Triple Sec
  • 2 dashes orange bitters
  • 2 slices jalapeno - thinly sliced and seeded or candied jalapenos
  • 1/2 lime - cut into wedges to wet the rim for the salt
  • 2 T clear rimming sugar - or other large crystal sugar
  • 1 t chipotle chili powder - or other spicy chili powder


To Make 2 Cocktails

  • In a pint glass muddle 1/2 an orange, lime with orange bitters, add simple syrup, and lime juice
  • Transfer all ingredients to a large cocktail shaker filled with ice and add tequila, Cointreau, and orange juice.
  • Shake until very cold.
  • Add the jalapenos, for a milder flavor try using candied jalapenos. The recipe is in the notes section.
  • Mix sugar and chili powder on a plate
  • Rub the rims glasses with a lime wedge and dip in salt to coat
  • Serve the margaritas in the prepared glasses over ice and garnish with the lime slices.

To make a pitcher

  • To make a pitcher add all ingredients to a pitcher filled with ice and stir vigorously.
  • Once well-chilled remove ice so it doesn't dilute your cocktail before serving
  • Serve over ice




  1. Slice jalapenos into rounds.
  2. Remove seeds, wear gloves when working with hot peppers.
  3. Place jalapenos in a small saucepan.
  4. Add water and sugar.
  5. Cook over medium/high heat until boiling.
  6. Reduce temperature and simmer for 30 - 40 minutes until the liquid has reduced and is syrupy, stirring occasionally.
  7. Use immediately or let cool to room temperature then place in jar and store in the refrigerator.
  8. Stored in the refrigerator they will keep for about a week.


Calories: 340kcal | Carbohydrates: 47g | Protein: 2g | Fat: 1g | Saturated Fat: 1g | Sodium: 31mg | Potassium: 388mg | Fiber: 5g | Sugar: 37g | Vitamin A: 1397IU | Vitamin C: 156mg | Calcium: 44mg | Iron: 1mg
Did you love this recipe? Please Share!Mention @MermaidsandMojitos or tag #mermaidsandmojitos!
  • Save


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  • Save
Learn WordPress 50% off
  • Save

Recent Posts

    • Save
    Homemade Blueberry Lemon Scones
    There's nothing better than delicious homemade blueberry lemon scones. Topped with a little honey butter lemon blueberry scones are amazing. […]
  • tequila mockingbird cocktail
    • Save
    Tequila Mockingbird – Spicy Tequila Cocktail
    Tequila Mockingbird - Spicy Tequila Cocktail. Muddled watermelon and fresh jalapeno with tequila is the perfect balance of spicy and sweet. […]
  • Cafe Brulot
    • Save
    Café Brûlot – New Orleans Flaming Coffee
    Café Brûlot - New Orleans Flaming Coffee is a very impressive way to finish a wonderful meal. In many of New Orleans grand old French-Creole restaurants, like Arnaud's, Antoine's or Galatoire's this is the grand finale of the meal. Flaming brandy-spiked coffee spiked with a touch of citrus and cinnamon. […]
  • Sausage and peppers
    • Save
    Grilled Sausage and Peppers Recipe
    My Philly husband loves sausage and peppers. I've adapted the traditional recipe so that it can be the centerpiece of our backyard barbecues. The peppers and onions steam perfectly in foil packs and grilling the sausage bring out the smoky flavor of the hot Italian sausage. We have the perfect sausage and peppers, now if I could just get Cacia's or Sarcone's rolls in Florida... […]
  • S'Mores station courtesy of Hi Miss puff
    • Save
    Creative Ideas for a S’mores Making Station
    6 Creative Ideas for an S'Mores making station. S'Mores are a fun finish to any backyard barbecue, bonfire or campfire. Here are some great ideas for S'more making stations that look great and make it easy for guest to create their S'Mores creation. […]
Work Anywhere
  • Save

More Recipe(

 < Eat  < Drink < Party <

  • Save


  • Save

DIY + Create


Food Philosophy

I love serving homemade meals and entertaining, but I don’t love spending all my time in the kitchen… Sound familiar?  I’ll share my shortcuts for getting delicious, healthy food on the table – easy, fast & stress-free. All of my recipes have been tested on family and friends.  We love them and I hope you will too.

  • Save


Chief Mermaid & Mojito Maker

This is me hangin’ out on the boat – it’s an absolutely gorgeous day in the Florida Keys – doing what wannabe mermaids do best…splashing in the waves + soaking up the sun. Life’s amazing.  Want to learn more?  
Spicy Orange Muddled Margarita Recipe
I love margaritas and I especially love muddled margaritas.  Muddling the fruit all the flavor of both the juice and the zest. via @mermaidsandmojitos
  • Save

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This

Share the Love.

Tell your friends!

Share via
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap